Evanston, IL 60201 2309 Foster Street

2309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 12309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 22309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 3
40 more
2309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 42309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 52309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 62309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 72309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 82309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 92309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 102309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 112309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 122309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 132309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 142309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 152309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 162309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 172309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 182309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 192309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 202309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 212309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 222309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 232309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 242309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 252309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 262309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 272309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 282309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 292309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 302309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 312309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 322309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 332309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 342309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 352309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 362309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 372309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 382309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 392309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 402309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 412309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 422309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 432309 Foster Street Evanston, IL - Image 44
Presented By: eXp Realty
  • MLS# 12464397
  • 09/05/2025
  • Request Tour
  • Request Info
  • Beds • 4
  • Baths • 3

Home Details

Investment opportunity in Evanston! This versatile duplex offers a rare combination of strong rental income, flexible layout, and house-hacking potential. Featuring a total of 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, plus a unique heated bonus room with closet, the property works for both savvy investors looking for cash flow and owner-occupants hoping to produce rental income. Unit 1 (Main Level) includes 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and a bonus room that has been successfully leased as a third bedroom for the past two years. It is currently occupied by a Housing Authority of Cook County (HACC) voucher tenant with a lease in place through April 2026. The unit rents for $2,899 per month, with the tenant paying $399 and HACC paying $2,500 directly to the landlord. This stable lease provides reliable, guaranteed income for the next owner. Unit 2 (Top Floor) offers 2 bedrooms and 1 bathroom. It has undergone recent updates, including a full kitchen renovation in 2022. For the past three years, it was rented to a HACC voucher tenant at $2,100 per month ($1,366 paid by HACC). The unit is now vacant, creating flexibility for the new buyer: lease it out immediately to a new tenant, or occupy it as an owner while keeping Unit 1 rented to cover a substantial portion of your expenses. Key highlights include: unique bonus room with heat and closet expanding usability of Unit 1, strong rental history with long-term Housing Authority tenants, attractive financing potential when purchased as a primary residence, use of Unit 1's guaranteed income to strengthen financing options and significantly reduce out-of-pocket housing costs, a recently updated Unit 2 that is move-in ready and ideal for tenants or an owner-occupant, and professional property management available and ready to assist with leasing Unit 2 for the next owner, ensuring a seamless transition. As-Is sale. Please respect tenant privacy - no showings of Unit 1 until after contract acceptance. With one unit already generating strong income and the second unit vacant and ready, this property practically pays for itself. Investors will appreciate the stability of a long-term HACC lease and the upside of leasing the second unit at market or voucher rates. Owner-occupants will love the ability to live in a renovated unit while dramatically reducing monthly housing expenses. This is a rare chance to secure an income-producing property in Evanston with both stability and growth potential. Contact us today for details and to take advantage of this excellent opportunity. Agent-owned.
Presented By: eXp Realty

Interior Features for 2309 Foster Street

Bedrooms

Bedrooms Possible4
Total Bedrooms4

Bathrooms

Full Baths Building3
Half Baths Building
Total Baths3

Other Interior Features

BasementUnfinished, Full
Total Number of Units2

General for 2309 Foster Street

CityEvanston
Construction MaterialsVinyl Siding
CountyCook
DirectionsHead west on Emerson St at Golf Rd then make left turn on Foster St
Elementary SchoolLincoln Elementary School
Elementary School District156
Gross Income34788
HeatingNatural Gas
High SchoolEvanston Twp High School
High School District202
MLS AreaEvanston
Middle/Junior High SchoolHaven Middle School
Middle/Junior School District65
ModificationTimestamp2025-09-11T05:07:24.573Z
New ConstructionNo
OwnershipFee Simple
PossessionClosing
Property TypeResidential Income
Property TypeTwo to Four Units
SewerPublic Sewer
Standard StatusActive
StatusActive
Tax Annual Amount6052.25
Tax Year2023
Total Rooms9
TownshipEvanston
Year Built1909

Exterior for 2309 Foster Street

Lot Dimensions27X125
OwnerPhone224-420-0805
Total Parking0
Water SourcePublic
Waterfront Y/NNo

Additional Details

Price History

Schools

Elementary School Lincoln Elementary School
Middle School Haven Middle School
High School Evanston Twp High School

Client Care

Price $459,999
MLS#12464397
List Date 09/05/2025
Property Type Multi-Family
Phone 847.485.2500
Request Tour
Request Info
Visit My Website

Similar Properties to 2309 Foster Street